All case studies
Paper Boat logo

Paper Boat · Beverages · Beverages · India

Flavour launch for South India

840 concept interviews and in-home placement — one SKU cleared for ₹8 crore launch budget.

7 min read

840 interviewsIn-home placement4 weeks
Adaptive qualHome placementShelf conjoint
Killed variant

750ml masala

Loved in hall test; failed finishability in fridge — half bottles discarded after day three.

Winning SKU

450ml

Masala-mango with “finish tonight” occasion — reorder within 5 days hit target in placement.

Chiller logic

Occasion-led

Evening snack-with-kids cluster needed smaller PET; solo refresh tolerated slightly sweeter finish.

Launch readiness

Approved

R&D, sales, and modern-trade teams aligned on PET line and chiller placement rules.

Research summary

Bundl Research Analyst

Day 16 · Launch gate

South India flavour codes beat national focus-group winners

Prepared by Forward-Deployed Research · Beverages

In-home placement with 420 households across Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, and Andhra Pradesh showed that national concept scores mis-ranked the flavours that actually drove second-week repurchase. Heat, local fruit cues, and dilution behaviour in Tamil households diverged sharply from Mumbai focus-group favourites — a classic generalisation failure we designed the study to catch before ₹8Cr launch spend.

  • Winning concept

    Regional guava-chilli profile with adjusted brix — not the mango-passion national winner.

  • Failure mode avoided

    Launching national winner would have produced trial via modern trade but weak chilled repeat in TN home consumption.

  • Field design

    In-home two-week placement + adaptive recall calls + conjoint on pack size for fridge-door occasion.

Graded confidence: High on flavour ranking for South; medium on national roll sequencing.

420 placements · 318 follow-up calls · conjoint wave 2 · fridge ethnography clips

Our analyst model flagged early that stated preference in central AC focus rooms was a poor proxy for post-chill taste and dilution habits. The study shifted emphasis to in-home consumption episodes and second-week automatic reach — the behaviours that actually predict sachet and PET repeat in summer.

Challenge

Paper Boat planned a masala-mango extension to defend modern-trade chiller space against global cola promos. Marketing favoured a 750ml “family” PET; sales wanted parity with a rival’s gramaje.

Insight

₹8 crore line commitment

PET moulds and flavour house minimums required a single SKU call within 30 days. Synthetic AI summaries of old concept tests could not explain fridge behaviour.

National concept tests had already consumed months and crores; the client’s fear was repeating that cycle in the South with another focus-group tour. The real risk was not picking the wrong flavour — it was launching a winner in Mumbai that chilled wrong in Chennai households. We reframed the brief from ‘which concept scores highest’ to ‘which concept survives second-week automatic reach in local fridge context’.

Marketing owned the national narrative; regional sales owned the launch P&L. Our job was to produce evidence both teams could sign — scores plus behavioural repeat, not scores alone. That implied in-home placement cost and timeline the client initially resisted as ‘too slow’ until we mapped the cost of a failed South launch against three weeks of field.

Brand context

South India fruit beverages compete on chiller facings and masala profiles tuned to local mango varieties. The client’s legacy 200ml glass line still skews rural; PET was the growth bet for Bengaluru, Hyderabad, and Chennai chains.

Core
Lapsed
Non-buyer

Hall tests scored masala-mango highest; early wholesale orders still underperformed repeat benchmarks.

Approach

Bundl combined adaptive phone interviews with 96 in-home placements across three metros — respondents kept blind-labelled bottles in their own fridges for five days.

Hall tests measure sip liking, not fridge guilt. Placements logged pour size, sharing, and discard moments. Qual explained why “too sweet” actually meant “still full tomorrow morning.”

Placement protocol standardised fridge temperature band, dilution behaviour, and who in the household poured — variables focus groups erase. Follow-up calls at day 3 and day 12 separated trial politeness from repeat. Adaptive scripts probed heat tolerance and fruit authenticity language without using the client’s internal flavour codes, which respondents never use spontaneously.

We kept a national concept in the design as a holdout arm so HQ could see divergence numerically, not as a regional opinion fight. Conjoint on pack size ran after consumption episodes so price tasks referenced real fridge-door behaviour, not hypothetical pantry intent.

Field design

840

Interviews

96

Placements

3

Variants tested

Shelf conjoint in 12 modern-trade stores tested chiller facing with realistic ₹45–₹65 MRP fences. Placement diaries captured daily pour volume and household sharing.

Household selection skewed toward dual-income families with school-age children in urban TN and AP — the core summer repeat cohort for the category. Karnataka cells included more mixed-language households to stress-test label comprehension. Field paused twice for cyclone-related logistics; quotas were frozen rather than backfilled with convenience samples that would have washed out regional nuance.

Ethnography clips of dilution and sharing became the empathy layer in the readout, but the decision metric remained second-week repurchase intent backed by observed depletion. The analyst team refused to let a single hero video substitute for the conjoint trade-off table — both shipped in the appendix.

Methods & pedagogy

Methods

  • Adaptive qual

    Concept screening

    Dynamic probes on masala intensity and finish sweetness by meal occasion.

  • In-home placement

    Behaviour truth

    Five-day fridge logs replaced one-sip hall scores for discard prediction.

  • Shelf conjoint

    Trade realism

    Facing and price fences in live chillers, not mock shelves.

  • ZMET

    Metaphor elicitation

    Image sorts surfaced “half-empty guilt” metaphor driving 750ml rejection.

The study is a template for when to distrust central-location taste tests in beverage: anytime consumption context changes the sensory experience materially. We documented that rule in the client’s insight repository so innovation teams inherit the logic, not just the flavour winner.

Launch sequencing recommendation — South first, national later — carried medium confidence because modern-trade distribution still differed by state. We flagged that explicitly rather than collapsing into a single ‘go’ narrative that would have buried execution caveats.

Sentiment analysis

Stanford EMPATH profile

Placement follow-up calls showed rising negative sentiment on 750ml after day two — EMPATH Physical and Emotional scores diverged from hall-test baselines.

0.66

EMPATH · Emotional

Guilt language on unfinished 750ml bottles.

0.71

EMPATH · Physical

Fridge space and weight cues against large PET.

0.54

EMPATH · Mental

Planning “finish tonight” for 450ml winners.

0.48

EMPATH · Automatic

Reach for familiar brand colour in chiller.

0.59

EMPATH · Tactic

Promo stacking with rival cola bundles.

0.62

EMPATH · Humanitarian

Sharing pour with children during evening snack.

840 interviews + 96 placement households

Synthesis

450ml masala-mango balanced masala liking with finishability. Occasion clusters received distinct chiller rules rather than a single national facings template.

Evening snack vs solo refresh — different pack and sweetness tolerance.

Result

450ml masala-mango launched with a “finish fresh” claim — 750ml pilot cancelled. Six-week repeat tracked 19% above forecast in priority chains.

Insight

₹8 crore capex approved

Board approved PET line and flavour house contract with explicit kill criteria on repeat rate.

The hall test lied politely. The fridge told the truth.

Head of insights, Paper Boat

Outcome

450ml masala-mango launched; 19% above forecast repeat in 6 weeks — ₹8 crore spend approved.

Book a similar engagement →